9 of the best site speed tools

Sam Underwood
Sam Underwood
November 5, 2019
11 mins read

Most digital marketers nowadays realise the importance of site speed and its impact on how users feel about your brand. People hate wasting their time waiting for loading bars to fill. Unfortunately, if your site doesn't fulfil the high expectations put on load times the only thing you will gain is a frustrated customer with a poor perception of your brand

When it comes to speed, first impressions count.

The great thing about site speed being widely regarded as a key metric to impacting conversion rate is that there are now loads of great site speed tools to diagnose and monitor your site.

The first range of tools sit firmly within the diagnosis category of tools, they give you insights into what exactly is wrong and then what you need to do to fix them. There are plenty of these available and to be honest, a lot of them don't do anything new.

The second group of tools are to do with monitoring, and I'm seeing more and more of these types of speed tools come out. A lot of these monitoring tools usually make use of ongoing reports from the fantastic Google-made Lighthouse tool as well as their open-sourced Chrome User Experience Report data.

What is the Chrome User Experience Report?

The Chrome User Experience Report (CrUX) gives various user experience metrics gathered from real-world Chrome users. The data it gives is freely available and queryable from a BigQuery database.

Within this article, I'm going to run through both types of tools and provide some recommendations for which ones I recommend!

Site speed diagnosis tools

First, I'm going to run through some of the top diagnosis tools to use. Rather than list every tool out there, these are just the crème de la crème of the diagnostic tools that you should be making use of.

PageSpeed Insights

This one should be an obvious one! PageSpeed Insights has been around for a long time now and its recent update and introduction of lighthouse metrics combined with CrUX field data has made it even more valuable.

When diagnosing a site this is usually my first port-of-call primarily due to it reporting back user-centric performance metrics.

The basis of the tool is that you want to be aiming for a high-score. It has two tabs, one for mobile and one for desktop. The mobile tab is the default and this is where you should focus. We usually focus on making improvements here as the tab simulates what could be considered the worst-case scenario for site speed.

Majority of the web is now mobile and it mosts cases so will your site's traffic. If you manage to get good scores on mobile, then desktop will be really quick.

pagespeed insights screenshot
Since I offer site speed auditing, I don't really have an excuse to not do well here...

For mobile, the tool simulates a mid-tier device (Moto G4) on a mobile network (roughly 1.6Mbps down / 750 Kbps up with a latency of 150ms).

After the score, the tool gives you 'field data'. This is data that is collected from actual users visiting your site. The speeds are categorised as fast (green), moderate (yellow) and slow (red).

image 6
Disclaimer: This isn't my site or a clients! We'd do much better than this

If you go further down the page, you get what is called 'lab data'. This is a snapshot of what your performance was like when the lighthouse tool checked your page when you clicked analyze.

image 4
This is one of my sites, nailed it! If you're unsure what some of the above metrics mean, click the icon highlighted above.

To the next section, the tool gives you a variety of insights into ways in which you can improve your site speed.

image 7

The great thing about a lot of the advice given here is that these aren't things you'll find in any other tools. A lot of the time you will find other tools not making use of Lighthouse will say you've got high scores and then you'll try out PageSpeed Insights and found lots of issues.

This is all due to PageSpeed Insights focusing on ways in which to improve perceived performance rather than just your final page load time. Obviously a lot of these will also impact your total page load time, but its more important to a user how quickly your content is visible and that they can interact with the page, which is exactly what PageSpeed Insights shows.

Tools that use page load times as a metric to focus on would highlight that some external JS file is loading slow in the background, but it's not impacting the user's experience on the site, so is it really important?

Probably not.

One additional thing to consider with this tool is that it is incredibly time-consuming to get a perfect 100 score, especially on mobile. Eventually, you will get to a point of diminishing returns so try not to obsess over the score, utilise the field data and just make sure your users are having a good experience on your site.

web.dev

Next up we've got the measure tool at web.dev. We won't linger too long on this one as essentially, it's a reskin of PageSpeed Insights with some additional Lighthouse reporting around accessibility, SEO, best practices and without the CrUX field data.

web dev screen

One handy additional feature you will find here is the ability to create an account and track your site performance over time using Lighthouse. All free-of-charge.

GTMetrix

GTMetrix is a great tool that combines speed diagnosis from the older version of PageSpeed Insights alongside YSlow. It also has a page timings report, a nice waterfall chart and it can also do a video recording of your page loading.

One thing I'd love to see in this tool is for it to remove the focus on the 'fully loaded time' metric. This site is actually a great example of why.

We have a relatively high fully loaded time considering how well we score in PageSpeed Insights. The reason why is because we preload other URLs into the browser once it has finished downloading the current page, this makes the load times almost instant when the user navigates to the next page. You can see that happening at the bottom of the Waterfall chart in GTMetrix:

image 12

If you go into the timings report, you can see my site looks a lot faster:

image 13

Pingdom

Pingdom's site speed tool is another great tool to take a quick check of your site speed. It includes similar suggestions to GTMetrix, albeit with no examples.

image 14

For example, for the above suggestions, Pingdom doesn't feedback which files aren't being compressed with GZIP which is a shame.

What is really handy within Pingdom is the overview it gives on requests and file sizes by type alongside requests and size by domain:

image 16

This can be useful so you know where you should focus your speed optimisation efforts. For example, if you can see images are making up most of your file size, maybe take a look at compressing them/reducing quality, lazy loading or converting them to an image format like WebP.

Similar to GTMetrix, there is also a really handy waterfall chart at the bottom.

image 17

Speed monitoring tools

Next, I'm going to run through some of my favourite performance monitoring tools. It's essential to look into some way of managing performance on an ongoing basis to ensure overtime you don't start adding more and more bloat to your site.

You can prevent adding bloat to your site by getting processes in place to monitor and by setting performance budgets. The below tools will help with this!

Calibre

A personal favourite of mine is called Calibre. It's a bit more of a premium tool but it is also very feature-rich at the same time.

The tool is again based on Lighthouse data, which is great. The tool allows you to run Lighthouse reports overtime on a schedule and stores that information which makes it ideal for spotting trends.

One thing we love about this tool is that it allows you to run Lighthouse reports with custom network conditions, URLs and devices that you can choose. For example, if you know most of your users use an Apple iPhone and they have more money to spend, you can set up a device as a higher-end iPhone and track what performance would be like on that device.

image 8

It doesn't just give you the top-level performance scores either, you can also see all the other scores Lighthouse reports on.

image 9

Alongside that, it also has a range of other features including:

  • Performance budget management
  • Third-party script tracking
  • A great alerts system revolved around the budgets you set as well as a weekly/monthly performance summary

Speedcurve

Speedcurve is another great option for speed monitoring offerring a wide range of every-growing features such as:

  • Performance budget management
  • An impressive performance alerts system
  • A changes report that highlights important changes for the site
  • Daily performance measuring with great data visualisation, this is probably the best tool for it!
  • A real user monitoring (RUM) solution called LUX. This isn't CrUX data at involves adding a JS snippet to your site, so arguably better than CrUX as you can measure the speed for all your users, not just those on Chrome that allows browser data to be shared.
  • Light and dark themes ?
image 21

This tool is incredibly feature-rich and a great all-in-one solution for site speed monitoring. I use this tool a lot and it works brilliantly.

The team at Speedcurve are also constantly rolling out new features, so if you're looking for a tool that is always at the forefront of speed measurement and diagnosis this is a great option.

SpeedMonitor.io

SpeedMonitor.io is a great cheaper alternative to Calibre that doesn't quite have all the same features, but it's still great. The principle of it is very much the same as Calibre with it utilising Lighthouse data and storing it daily.

One thing we love about Speedmonitor.io is that it also captures and stores data from the Chrome UX Report which shows actual speed from users on your site. Really handy!

image 18

Some further features include:

  • Competitor comparisons (really useful to make a business case for focusing on site speed)
  • Slack notifications around site speed!
  • On-demand one-off audits

Google Search Console speed report

The Google Search Console (GSC) team also recently released an incredibly useful site speed report that utilises CrUX data and it is free! It is still experimental at the moment but it is a great addition to the GSC toolset.

The report is found on the left sidebar under in the enhancements section and it is called simply called Speed:

image 20

The report is split out between mobile and desktop, it also categorises all URLs on your site within the CrUX database as either slow, average or fast.

You can then go into each section and it'll list the problem URLs individually, when you click on a URL it gives you a quick link to PageSpeed Insights so you can run a Lighthouse report and see what the potential issues are.

image 22

Now, it's important to remember that this is based on real-world data. That means if a URL is loading slow for a user, it may just be because they were on a poor connection. You should however still take a look at the page to see if there is anything you can do to optimise it, it may just be that you've got a large unoptimised image on the page.

Data Studio

Thanks to the CrUX data studio integration, you can quite easily get yourself set up with a measurement report that reports historic data for how fast your site has been for users for free.

crux dashboard

I've got this in my reporting suite and use it across all of my clients. What's even handier is that you could also add some competitors to a dashboard like this and do some like-for-like comparisons for how quickly your site is compared to theirs.

I have written up a guide on setting up a data studio CrUX dashboard here.

Wrapping up

With the above site speed tools, you will be able to effectively diagnose and monitor your site's performance. After that, you've just got the hard part of actually making the improvements to your site!

Any new tools you've been trying out to measure performance? Let me know in the comments and I'll get them added to the list!

linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram